The National Times - Turkish court says Erdogan had right to annul women's treaty

Turkish court says Erdogan had right to annul women's treaty


Turkish court says Erdogan had right to annul women's treaty
Turkish court says Erdogan had right to annul women's treaty / Photo: © AFP

Turkey's top court on Tuesday ruled that President Recep Tayyip Erdogan had the right to pull his country out of a European convention against gender-based violence.

Change text size:

Rights groups and Western governments voiced shock and outrage when Erdogan cancelled Turkey's membership of the Istanbul Convention in an overnight decree last year.

Erdogan's political opponents argued the president did not have the power to unilaterally annul membership of an international agreement.

Turkey became the first country to sign the convention in 2011 and ratified it by vote in parliament the following year.

But the top administrative court on Tuesday rejected a request to overturn Erdogan's decision in a case involving testimony from leading women's rights groups and legal scholars.

The court's five judges ruled in a 3-2 vote that a president's decision could not be subject to a legal review.

The two dissenting judges said in a separate opinion that Erdogan's actions overstepped his legal bounds.

A lawyer representing the We Will Stop Femicide Platform rights organisation said the ruling was "tantamount to rejecting the constitution".

"It is terrifying from a legal perspective," lawyer Ipek Bozkurt told AFP. "This erroneous decision should have been stopped by the court."

The treaty -- now enacted by dozens of European countries -- requires member states to adopt domestic legislation that strictly punishes domestic abuse and gender-based violence.

But Erdogan's Islamic conservative supporters argued that its language harmed traditional family values and promoted LGBTQ rights.

Erdogan's main opponents in next year's general election immediately rose to the treaty's defence.

Main opposition leader Kemal Kilicdaroglu vowed to sign Turkey back up to the convention should he become president in the July 2023 vote.

"I can make a promise to the nation," the CHP party leader said.

"When we come to power -- and we will, with God's permission and the nation's approval -- in the first week, even in the first 24 hours, we will implement the Istanbul Convention," Kilicdaroglu told reporters.

Nationalist Iyi (Good) Party leader Meral Aksener accused the court of issuing "a political decision (aimed) at pleasing a dirty mind".

A.Wood--TNT

Featured

Japan and Peru Mark 150 Years of Diplomatic Ties Amidst Trade and Investment Talks

Japan and Peru are commemorating more than 150 years of diplomatic relations as Peruvian President Keiko Fujimori visits Tokyo to strengthen economic ties. The visit highlights a deep historical connection rooted in late-19th-century migration and sustained by modern trade in critical minerals and strategic partnerships.

Hong Kong NGO Critiques Sex Crimes Law Overhaul Amid Consent Defense Concerns

A leading Hong Kong sexual violence advocacy group has identified significant deficiencies in the government’s proposed overhaul of the city’s sex crimes laws. The Association Concerning Sexual Violence Against Women outlined five key concerns regarding the draft legislation, particularly focusing on provisions that allow defendants to claim a mistaken belief in consent and the narrow scope of current definitions for oral sexual assault.

Malta PM Abela Refuses Parliamentary Question on Maritime Borders Amid Turkey-Libya Deal

Maltese Prime Minister Robert Abela refused to answer a parliamentary inquiry about the country’s maritime borders and exclusive economic zone, which Nationalist MP Eve Borg Bonello stated were threatened by a recent Turkey-Libya agreement. The dispute has prompted diplomatic engagement between Foreign Minister Chris Fearne and Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan.

Global Scams Remain Widespread: Nearly Two in Three Adults Worldwide Report Scam Encounters, 9% Lost Money

Global Anti-Scam Alliance and Outseer Release Global State of Scams 2026

Change text size: