The National Times - Judge sides with Elon Musk in lawsuit over SolarCity

Judge sides with Elon Musk in lawsuit over SolarCity


Judge sides with Elon Musk in lawsuit over SolarCity
Judge sides with Elon Musk in lawsuit over SolarCity / Photo: © POOL/AFP/File

A judge in the state of Delaware on Wednesday handed Tesla chief Elon Musk a victory in a shareholder lawsuit filed over the controversial buy of solar panel maker SolarCity.

Change text size:

The judge ruled against a group of Tesla shareholders who contended that Musk, who was chairman of both Tesla and SolarCity at the time of the transaction, "poisoned" Tesla's ability to fairly evaluate the purchase, wasting corporate assets in the $2.6 billion deal and harming people who owned Tesla stock, according to a complaint.

The judge wrote in his decision that evidence indicated Tesla paid a "fair price" for SolarCity and has benefited from the acquisition.

The group of investors, which includes union pension funds and other institutional investors, argued that SolarCity was a failing enterprise that faced "likely bankruptcy" were it not for the actions of Musk and other Tesla board members, who also had large equity stakes in SolarCity.

The shareholders who filed the suit had previously reached a $60 million settlement with other Tesla directors originally named in the complaint, with the payment coming from insurance. This group, which included Kimbal Musk, Elon Musk's brother, did not admit fault.

A key question in the trial was whether Musk, who held 22 percent of Tesla's equity at the time, controlled the transaction, which won approval from Tesla shareholders.

Musk told the court that buying SolarCity was part of his "master plan," according to CNBC.

Dan Ives, analyst at Wedbush Securities, said during the course of the trial that Wall Street was watching "very closely to see the outcome for Musk and the corporate governance."

The SolarCity deal has been a "black eye" for Musk and Tesla and a "clear low light" in the company's whirlwind rise, Ives said in a note late last year.

J.Sharp--TNT

Featured

Miao and Dong Traditional Knowledge Offers Climate Resilience Lessons at COP31

Traditional ecological practices from the Miao and Dong communities in Southwest China are being presented as vital models for climate resilience at the ongoing COP31 conference. A new report unveiled at the China Pavilion details how these time-honored methods offer sustainable alternatives to modern industrial agriculture and resource management.

Fiona the Hippo Dies After Ingesting Knit Hat; Veterinary Experts Explain Mechanism

Fiona, the nine-year-old hippo who gained global fame for surviving premature birth, has died at the Cincinnati Zoo following medical complications from ingesting a knit hat. Veterinary specialists attribute her death to an intestinal blockage that triggered toxic shock and organ failure, explaining why surgical intervention was deemed too risky for the massive animal.

Whale Watching Tour Near the Farallon Islands Reveals Harsh Ocean Conditions

A journey to the Farallon Islands aboard the vessel Salty Lady revealed the stark contrast between the rugged, bird-covered rocks and the open Pacific. The tour offered close encounters with harbor seals and whales amidst heavy fog and rough seas, underscoring the remote nature of this critical wildlife habitat.

India Ranks 10th in Climate Risk Index 2027 Amid 78,000 Deaths Since 1996

India has been ranked among the ten countries most vulnerable to extreme weather events since 1996, according to the Climate Risk Index 2027. Released by Germanwatch at COP31, the report highlights that floods, cyclones, and heatwaves have caused over 78,000 fatalities and $170 billion in economic losses across the nation.

Change text size: