The National Times - Texas law against blocking online posts on hold for now

Texas law against blocking online posts on hold for now


Texas law against blocking online posts on hold for now
Texas law against blocking online posts on hold for now / Photo: © GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA/AFP

The US Supreme Court on Tuesday put back on hold a controversial Texas law barring social media platforms from "censoring" posts based on viewpoints.

Change text size:

The law threatens to essentially make it a crime for social media platforms to curb hate speech or bigoted tirades, or even point out when posts are demonstrably false.

Political conservatives have accused Facebook, Twitter and other social media giants of stifling their voices, providing no evidence to support the claims.

Social media platforms have consistently defended themselves against such accusations, saying content moderation decisions are based on factors such as risk of real-world harm.

Former US president Donald Trump was booted from Facebook and Twitter after a group of his supporters attacked the Capitol on January 6, 2021 in an attempt to prevent his rightly elected successor Joe Biden from taking office.

People died during the attack, and there were concerns Trump would use social media to incite further violence.

The Texas law bars social media platforms with more than 50 million users from banning people based on their political viewpoints.

NetChoice trade association, whose members include Amazon, Facebook and Google, challenged the law and convinced a federal court in Texas to stop it from being enforced until it was resolved whether it runs afoul of the US Constitution's First Amendment.

An appeals court later sided with Texas, saying the state could go ahead with the law, prompting the matter being taken to the Supreme Court.

The top court in the United States on Tuesday backed the original decision to put Texas law HB 20 on hold while the question of whether it should be tossed out completely is resolved.

"Texas's HB 20 is a constitutional trainwreck -- or, as the district court put it, an example of 'burning the house to roast the pig,'" NetChoice counsel Chris Marchese said in a release.

"Despite Texas's best efforts to run roughshod over the First Amendment, it came up short in the Supreme Court."

NetChoice welcomed the decision, which sends the case back to a district court in Texas to hear arguments regarding the law's constitutionality.

In its original decision about the stay, the district court said social media platforms have a right to moderate content disseminated on their platforms, and that a provision against putting warning labels on misinformation even risked violating the free speech rights of internet firms.

"Texas's law violates the First Amendment because it compels social media companies to publish speech they don't want to publish, and because it prevents them from responding to speech they disagree with," said attorney Scott Wilkens at Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute.

"In addition, the theory of the First Amendment that Texas is advancing in this case would give government broad power to censor and distort public discourse."

S.Arnold--TNT

Featured

ALIX LASERS shareholders remove Michael Sobitsch as managing director in view of the circumstances

In an interview with BERLINER TAGESZEITUNG, the shareholders of Alix Lasers GmbH in Austria said that, after acquiring 100 per cent of the company’s shares, they removed Michael Sobitsch from his position as managing director yesterday, 19 November 2026, in Vienna, Austria. In view of the circumstances, they removed him from office with immediate effect, without granting him discharge for his tenure as managing director.

Analysts Identify Key Metal Stocks Amid 38% Commodity Slide

With silver, copper, and gold prices falling up to 38% from recent peaks due to global economic concerns, technical analysts at Angel One and SAMCO Securities have identified specific trading opportunities in major metal equities. The firms' research highlights both bearish setups for stocks like Hind Copper and SAIL, alongside potential bullish breakouts for APL Apollo Tubes and Jindal Stainless.

Saudi PIF Retains Top Sovereign Wealth Fund Brand Title for Third Year

Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund (PIF) has been named the world’s most valuable sovereign wealth fund brand for the third consecutive year, according to a new assessment by Brand Finance. The ranking highlights the fund's growing global influence and financial strength as it advances its strategic objectives under Vision 2030.

BING X: 22,624.66 SNC have disappeared at BingX – how safe are tokens on BingX? Will BingX’s MiCAR licence be suspended?

The BingX account showed 85,979.66 SNC as available and 0.00 SNC as frozen. Nevertheless, an employee of BING X, “BingX Ian” (Telegram account: @bingxianw), stated: “We are not having more SNC, you can withdraw 63,355 SNC now” – which means nothing other than that 22,624.66 SNC have simply disappeared at BING X and that BING X was apparently unable to protect these SNC SCANDIC COIN tokens against possible theft by its own staff, or that manipulation to benefit non-existent BING X liquidity has occurred!

Change text size: