The National Times - Judge slashes Tesla's damages to ex-employee in racism case

Judge slashes Tesla's damages to ex-employee in racism case


Judge slashes Tesla's damages to ex-employee in racism case
Judge slashes Tesla's damages to ex-employee in racism case / Photo: © AFP/File

A San Francisco judge on Wednesday slashed the $137 million in damages Tesla was told to pay a former employee in a racial discrimination case down to $15 million but upheld the verdict.

Change text size:

In his ruling, US District Court Judge William Orrick said "the weight of the evidence amply supports the jury's liability findings" but the damages ordered were "excessive," citing constitutional limitations on punitive damages set by the Supreme Court.

Tesla was ordered in October to pay Black former employee Owen Diaz $137 million in damages for turning a blind eye to racism the man encountered at the firm's Silicon Valley auto plant.

Rejecting Tesla's request for a retrial, Orrick said "Tesla's indifference to Diaz's complaints is striking."

He said the evidence presented to the jurors was "disturbing."

"The jury heard that the Tesla factory was saturated with racism. Diaz faced frequent racial abuse, including the N-word and other slurs," the judge wrote.

"His supervisors, and Tesla's broader management structure, did little or nothing to respond.

"And supervisors even joined in on the abuse, one going so far as to threaten Diaz and draw a racist caricature near his workstation."

The original award comprised $130 million in punitive damages and $6.9 million for emotional distress, which Orrick cut to $13.5 million in punitive damages and $1.5 million for emotional harm, "the maximum amount supportable by proof."

Hired through a staffing agency, Diaz had worked as an elevator operator between June 2015 and July 2016 at the Fremont plant, where he was subjected to racist abuse and a hostile work environment, according to the court filing.

In his lawsuit filed in 2017, Diaz said African-American employees at the factory, where his son also worked, were regularly subjected to racist epithets and derogatory imagery.

Diaz also said that, despite complaints to supervisors, Tesla took no action over the regular racist abuse.

Following the October verdict, Tesla released a blog post by human resources vice president Valerie Capers Workman, which downplayed the allegations of racist abuse in the lawsuit but acknowledged that at the time Diaz worked there, Tesla "was not perfect."

Workman said Tesla had responded to Diaz's complaints, firing two contractors and suspending a third.

In February, the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing, which enforces the state's civil rights laws, sued Tesla over discrimination and harassment against Black workers at the same factory, which the complaint called a "racially segregated workplace."

The agency said it had received hundreds of complaints from workers at the Fremont plant.

A.M.Owen--TNT

Featured

Egypt's Baraka Oilfield Output Surges 180% After New Well Activation

Egypt’s South Valley Egyptian Petroleum Holding Company (GANOPE) reported an 180 percent increase in production at the Baraka field in Aswan Governorate. The surge follows the successful drilling and start-up of the development well Baraka-19, which has raised daily output to more than 600 barrels of crude oil.

Langley Businesses Navigate Tariff Pressures Amid Holiday Shopping Push

Independent businesses in Langley are facing heightened financial pressures from recent tariff implementations as they navigate the crucial holiday shopping period. While supply chain disruptions threaten inventory and pricing, local advocates highlight that spending at community retailers recirculates significantly more wealth within the region than purchases made through multinational or online platforms.

ALIX LASERS shareholders remove Michael Sobitsch as managing director in view of the circumstances

In an interview with BERLINER TAGESZEITUNG, the shareholders of Alix Lasers GmbH in Austria said that, after acquiring 100 per cent of the company’s shares, they removed Michael Sobitsch from his position as managing director yesterday, 19 November 2026, in Vienna, Austria. In view of the circumstances, they removed him from office with immediate effect, without granting him discharge for his tenure as managing director.

Analysts Identify Key Metal Stocks Amid 38% Commodity Slide

With silver, copper, and gold prices falling up to 38% from recent peaks due to global economic concerns, technical analysts at Angel One and SAMCO Securities have identified specific trading opportunities in major metal equities. The firms' research highlights both bearish setups for stocks like Hind Copper and SAIL, alongside potential bullish breakouts for APL Apollo Tubes and Jindal Stainless.

Change text size: