The National Times - Court raps Brussels for lack of transparency on von der Leyen vaccine texts

Court raps Brussels for lack of transparency on von der Leyen vaccine texts


Court raps Brussels for lack of transparency on von der Leyen vaccine texts

A top court Wednesday ruled the European Commission failed the transparency test by declining to release text messages sent by Ursula von der Leyen to the head of Pfizer as the bloc tried to secure Covid vaccines.

Change text size:

Siding with The New York Times, which brought the case, the Court of Justice of the European Union (EUCJ) said the commission did not give "plausible" explanations as to why it did not hand over the texts to the US daily.

The ruling is a blow to von der Leyen, the commission president, and gives weight to critics who have accused her of centralised and opaque decision-making.

The verdict, which can be appealed, quashes the commission's decision not to hand over the messages and sends the EU executive back to the drawing board in its duty to respond to The New York Times' request.

However, given the uncertainty around whether the messages have been deleted or not, what happens next is not overly clear.

In a sharp rebuke of the EU's top leadership body, the Luxembourg based court wrote that "The Commission cannot merely state that it does not hold the requested documents."

It "failed to explain in a plausible manner why it considered that the text messages exchanged in the context of the procurement of Covid-19 vaccines did not contain important information," the court added in a statement.

The case centred on elusive exchanges between von der Leyen and Albert Bourla, chief executive of Pfizer -- which was chosen by the bloc as its main vaccine supplier at the height of the pandemic.

- Transparency -

The New York Times, which revealed the existence of the messages, sued the commission in 2023 after Brussels declined to produce them following a freedom of information request.

The commission argued it could not find the texts because they had not been recorded and archived -- something it says is done only when the content is deemed "substantive".

"The commission never denied the existence of text message exchanges," an EU official said ahead of the verdict. "What it was argued... is that these exchanges did not contain important information".

But such reasoning was rebuffed by the lower chamber of the EUCJ, which chastised the EU body for not having explained what searches it carried out to find the documents, and why it no longer had them.

"The Commission has not sufficiently clarified whether the requested text messages were deleted and, if so, whether the deletion was done deliberately or automatically or whether the President's mobile phone had been replaced in the meantime," it said.

The EU moved swiftly after the Covid pandemic emerged in 2020 to secure vaccines for member countries to buy for their citizens and residents at a time of massive global demand for the shots.

But many aspects of the procurement from Pfizer have been kept confidential, leading to claims of a lack of transparency -- and several legal proceedings in Belgium and with EU courts.

- 'Maladministration' -

"This case presents a very important issue: whether officials may evade public transparency by communicating via text messages rather than more traditional means," a lawyer for The Times, Bondine Kloostra, said in her opening arguments in November.

Lawyers for the 27-nation bloc argued the private messages did not constitute part of the vaccine negotiation.

They might have involved side issues, such as von der Leyen and Bourla agreeing to speak on a certain day, at a certain time, they suggested.

Earlier this week, an EU official argued commission workers, including its chief, do not have an obligation to record all their emails, texts and instant messaging chats, as this would be "materially impossible".

The commission's lawyer, Paolo Stancanelli, said in November that its services asked to track down the messages after The Times reached out to the EU chief's cabinet, which replied it was unable to find them.

But in January 2022, the EU's ombudsman had already described this as "maladministration", saying the messages should have been subject to the EU's public transparency rules for official documents.

C.Blake--TNT

Featured

Cardi B Wears Dramatic Feathered Headpiece at 2026 Baby2Baby Gala

Rapper Cardi B made a striking appearance at the 2026 Baby2Baby Gala in Los Angeles on November 15, donning a sculptural Tamara Ralph Spring 2026 Couture ensemble. The outfit featured a dramatic wide-brimmed headpiece adorned with white feathers and a cream-colored gown with gold detailing. B also performed at the charity event supporting children living in poverty.

Gypsy Rose Blanchard Links Leaked Calls to Ken Urker's Death in First TV Interview

Gypsy Rose Blanchard has spoken publicly for the first time regarding the death of Ken Urker, attributing his decline to the stress of leaked prison conversations and intense online harassment. In a candid interview with "60 Minutes Australia," Blanchard described Urker as the love of her life and firmly rejected insinuations that she played any role in his death.

Man Legally Changes Name to James Blunt After Six-Year Quest for Celebrity's Favorite Cheese

A British man has officially changed his legal name to James Délice de Bourgogne Blunt, fulfilling a long-standing personal wager with the singer-songwriter. The decision concludes a six-year campaign to discover the artist's preferred cheese, which was revealed as Délice de Bourgogne after Blunt’s album reached number one on the charts.

Niall Horan Fans Regret Missing Kingfishr Collaboration at Final Dublin Concert

Niall Horan concluded his four-night residency at Dublin’s 3Arena with a series of collaborations that left fans who missed the final date wishing they had been present. The singer performed alongside Irish indie folk group Kingfishr and paid an emotional tribute to late One Direction bandmate Liam Payne during the run.

Change text size: